Go Summarize

The "Yasuke" Disaster Is Ubisoft's Nightmare | Asmongold Reacts

Asmongold TV 2024-07-25
asmongold#asmongold reacts#asmongold wow#asmongold highlights#asmongold youtube#world of warcraft#asmongold funny#asmongold tv#asmongold channel#zackrawrr
459K views|1 months ago
💫 Short Summary

Assassin's Creed franchise faces accusations of cultural invasion by the Japanese government, particularly regarding the historical inaccuracies in the game set in feudal Japan featuring a black samurai, Yasuke. The controversy surrounding the portrayal of Yasuke raises questions about cultural representation and appropriation in gaming. Ubisoft's decision to stray from traditional characters related to their culture of origin has sparked debate on historical accuracy, diversity, and racism in video games. Despite the backlash, Assassin's Creed Shadows is expected to sell well, but concerns remain about the potential impact on future sales due to cultural insensitivity and historical inaccuracies.

✨ Highlights
📊 Transcript
✦
Assassin's Creed faces accusations of cultural invasion by the Japanese government due to historical revisionism in the franchise.
02:58
Despite controversies, Assassin's Creed remains one of the top-grossing franchises globally, with Valhalla being the highest-grossing entry.
The success of the series indicates a strong presence in the gaming landscape, with continuous growth in marketing and development budgets.
The upcoming entry, Shadows, set in feudal Japan, follows a trend of successful releases, potentially appealing to a wider audience.
The franchise's resilience and adaptability suggest continued success in the future.
✦
Backlash towards Ubisoft's game featuring a black samurai, Yasuke, due to cultural inaccuracies.
03:45
Controversy over the use of hip-hop infused music in a historical setting.
Yasuke's popularity in the West contrasted with criticisms over portrayal and historical accuracy.
Historian Thomas Illey credited for recognition of Yasuke in various media.
Discussions sparked on cultural representation and appropriation in gaming.
✦
The segment explores the rising Western media interest in Yasuke, focusing on edits made to his Wikipedia page by Thomas Illey.
09:18
Thomas Illey, a faculty member at Nihon University College of Law in Tokyo, is known for his interest in Japanese history.
Controversy surrounds Illey editing his own Wikipedia page, impacting modern depictions of Yasuke, notably in Assassin's Creed.
The discussion raises concerns about balancing historical accuracy and creative storytelling in popular media.
✦
Doubts about Yasuke's involvement in smuggling Nobunaga's head and sword out of Honji Temple.
12:29
Lack of concrete sources supporting the theory of Yasuke's role in the incident.
Discrepancies in translations and doubts expressed by the speaker regarding the credibility of the information.
Conflicting perspectives raise questions about the accuracy and reliability of historical accounts surrounding Yasuke's actions.
✦
Controversy surrounding the authenticity of Yasuke as a Samurai.
16:16
Thomas Ley accused of lying and manipulating information, editing the Yasuke Wikipedia page with false claims.
Ley cited his own unpublished work and falsely claimed an expert fact-checked his book.
Ley presents different versions of historical events to different audiences, called out for deceitful actions.
The Japan Times updated their article, removing false claims by Ley, exposing a pattern of dishonest behavior and manipulation of information.
✦
Controversy over Ubisoft's Assassin's Creed Shadows focusing on character Yasuke.
21:55
Debate over whether Yasuke was a samurai, retainer, or servant.
Thomas Illey argues Yasuke was a legendary samurai.
Conflicting historical perspectives and portrayal in the game spark interest.
Ubisoft's decision raises questions about cultural appropriation and historical accuracy in gaming.
✦
Cultural representation in video games and the use of historical characters.
24:25
Changing historical figures in an inauthentic way can be problematic and raises concerns about accuracy.
Debate on whether changes are for virtue signaling or to enhance the story.
Criticism of Assassin's Creed for using a non-traditional samurai character and incorporating a different cultural filter.
Questions about the portrayal of Japanese history and the choice of characters in the game, raising concerns about accuracy and cultural sensitivity.
✦
Ubisoft faces controversy over portrayal of Japanese historical figure in their game.
27:21
Critics question decision to deviate from previous Assassin's Creed games focused on characters from their culture.
Controversy brings up issues of historical accuracy and cultural sensitivity, raising concerns about rewriting history and racism.
Despite controversy, the game is expected to sell well, but may deliver a subpar experience.
Potential impact on future sales due to controversy surrounding cultural representation and diversity in the game.
✦
Critique of action combat games and design choices made by developers like Ubisoft.
29:15
Concerns raised about historical inaccuracies and cultural representation in games.
Call to support the channel through various means.
Criticism of the portrayal of black characters in video games and associated stereotypes.